Reproductive Endocrinology Ovulation Physiology

Effectiveness of levonorgestrel emergency contraception given before or after ovulation--a pilot study

Novikova N, Weisberg E, Stanczyk FZ, Croxatto HB, Fraser IS

Published February 2007 Contraception, 75(2), 112-8
DOI 10.1016/j.contraception.2006.08.015 PMID 17241840

RRM Academy Synopsis

Levonorgestrel pill appears to have little effect after ovulation

In a 2007 pilot study of 99 women, the authors say their data support the concept that the levonorgestrel emergency pill has little or no effect on events after ovulation. All three pregnancies, about 3 out of 100, came after pill use past ovulation, as estimated by blood hormone tests.

Key Findings

  • Women's self-report of their cycle stage differed greatly from the stage calculated from blood hormone levels.
  • Three of 99 women became pregnant (3.0%). With Day 0 as ovulation day, each had intercourse on Day -1 or Day 0 and took the pill on Day +2.
  • Among 17 women with intercourse in the fertile period who took the pill on Days +1 to +2, the authors said three or four pregnancies could have been expected. Three were observed.
  • Among 34 women with intercourse on Days -5 to -2 who took the pill on or before ovulation day, the authors noted that four pregnancies could have been expected. None occurred.

Interpretation

This synopsis rests on the published abstract alone. The work is a pilot study in which each woman took the pill during her clinic visit and was followed up 4 to 6 weeks later to ascertain pregnancy status. The authors estimated the timing of ovulation from blood hormones to within plus or minus 24 hours, with an accuracy of around 80%. They conclude that the data support the concept that the pill has little or no effect on events after ovulation.

RRM Context

The authors found major discrepancies between what women reported about their cycle stage and what hormone testing showed. That gap shows why cycle knowledge matters. Charting methods in restorative reproductive medicine teach women to read their own fertility signs and build body literacy.

Abstract

Background

Although widely used, the mechanisms of action of the levonorgestrel emergency contraceptive pill (LNG ECP) are still unclear. There are increasing data to indicate that LNG is particularly effective as an ECP by interrupting follicular development and ovulation. An important outstanding question is whether it has any effect on fertilization or implantation.

Method

Ninety-nine women participated; they were recruited at the time they presented with a request for emergency contraception. All women took LNG 1.5 mg in a single dose during the clinic consultation. A blood sample was taken immediately prior to ingestion of the ECP for estimation of serum LH, estradiol and progesterone levels to calculate the day of ovulation. The specimens were analyzed in a single batch. Based on these endocrine data, we estimated the timing of ovulation to be within a +/-24-h period with an accuracy of around 80%. Women were followed up 4-6 weeks later to ascertain pregnancy status. The effectiveness of ECP when taken before and after ovulation was determined.

Results

Three women became pregnant despite taking the ECP (pregnancy rate, 3.0%). All three women who became pregnant had unprotected intercourse between Days -1 and 0 and took the ECP on Day +2, based on endocrine data. Day 0 was taken as ovulation day. Among 17 women who had intercourse in the fertile period of the cycle and took the ECP after ovulation occurred (on Days +1 to +2), we could have expected three or four pregnancies; three were observed. Among 34 women who had intercourse on Days -5 to -2 of the fertile period and took ECP before or on the day of ovulation, four pregnancies could have been expected, but none were observed. We found major discrepancies between women's self-report of stage of the cycle and the dating calculation based on endocrine data.

Conclusion

These data are supportive of the concept that the LNG ECP has little or no effect on postovulation events but is highly effective when taken before ovulation.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Reproductive Endocrinology › Ovulation Physiology › Anovulation · Contraception › Emergency Contraception › Mechanism and Effectiveness · Therapeutics › Hormonal Agents › Progesterone and Progestins
Natalia Novikova, Edith Weisberg, Frank Z Stanczyk, Horacio B Croxatto, Ian S Fraser
N Novikova, E Weisberg, F Stanczyk, H Croxatto, I Fraser
PMID 17241840 17241840 DOI 10.1016/j.contraception.2006.08.015 10.1016/j.contraception.2006.08.015 Novikova et al. 2007, Novikova 2007