Ethics and Policy Policy and Regulation
RRM Academy Synopsis
HFEA Code of Practice sets guidance for UK fertility clinics
The HFEA Code of Practice (version 9.4, October 2023) gives UK licensed fertility centers regulatory principles and 33 guidance notes. The Code helps licensed centers comply with the 1990 UK law on fertility treatment and embryo research. Version 9.4 reflects storage law in force from 1 July 2022.
Key Findings
- The Code lists 13 regulatory principles, including regard for the embryo's special status and valid consents before licensed activity.
- Every one of the 33 guidance notes addresses a single subject area and separates legal requirements, the HFEA's interpretation of them, practical guidance and pointers to outside sources.
- Guidance note 7 limits transfer to three eggs or two embryos in one treatment cycle for a woman under 40 treated with her own eggs or embryos made from them.
- Guidance note 9 says centers should tell patients before consent that more robust trials are needed to assess whether PGT-A significantly increases live birth rates.
- Gametes and embryos kept for treatment must not be stored beyond a period not exceeding 55 years. Storage for a patient's own treatment needs written consent renewed every 10 years.
Interpretation
The Code is a regulator's guidance document for centers licensed under the Act. The HFEA publishes it to help those centers comply with the Act. The Code states that it does not cover every legal requirement, and that its interpretations only aid understanding. Some provisions apply only to Northern Ireland or only to Great Britain.
RRM Context
The Code governs IVF and related licensed activity in the United Kingdom. IVF bypasses the reproductive system and leaves open why conception fails. Restorative reproductive medicine evaluates and treats that cause. Guidance note 9 directs centers to tell patients before PGT-A consent that more robust trials are needed. The open question is whether PGT-A significantly increases live birth rates.
Abstract
The HFEA Code of Practice, 9th edition, published by the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority, was first published in January 2019 as version 9.1 and revised in December 2019 (version 9.2), October 2021 (version 9.3) and October 2023 (version 9.4). The Code states that the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990 covers the use and storage of sperm, eggs and embryos for human application and all research involving live human and admixed embryos, and that the Code is published to help licensed centres comply with the Act. The Code contains regulatory principles for licensed centres and 33 guidance notes, each covering one subject area through mandatory requirements, interpretation of mandatory requirements, guidance, and other legislation, professional guidelines and information. According to the document, the Code does not provide a complete guide to the Act and other mandatory requirements, and version 9.4 was updated in October 2023 to reflect new storage law that came into effect on 1 July 2022.


