Laparoscopically assisted transvaginal segmental resection of the rectosigmoid colon for endometriosis

Redwine DB, Koning M, Sharpe DR

Published January 1996 Fertility and Sterility, 65(1), 193-197
DOI 10.1016/s0015-0282(16)58051-0

RRM Academy Synopsis

Transvaginal bowel surgery for endometriosis came with shorter stays

In five women at one Oregon practice, bowel surgery through the vagina, guided by a camera, came with shorter hospital stays and lower charges than open surgery, a 1996 study found. Ten women had open surgery. Three had fully laparoscopic surgery.

Key Findings

  • Surgeons removed part of the lower colon in three ways: fully laparoscopic (3 women), laparoscopically assisted transvaginal (5 women), or laparotomy (10 consecutive women matched for bowel disease extent).
  • Against laparotomy, the transvaginal route meant a shorter hospital stay, operating room charges that were equivalent, and lower total hospital charges.
  • Average operating time for transvaginal surgery was faster than fully laparoscopic surgery and slightly slower than laparotomy.
  • No woman had an intestinal complication. One transvaginal patient needed office treatment for lingering granulation tissue at the vaginal incision.
  • The authors' referral practice treated 1,545 women surgically for endometriosis. Of these, 415 had intestinal disease, leading to 113 segmental colonic resections.

Interpretation

This retrospective study followed one private practice in a rural Oregon hospital. The authors note that hospital charges are not the same as hospital costs. They call the technique promising and best suited to low rectosigmoid lesions. The findings support larger studies of this approach.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine aims to find and remove the cause of disease. Every woman here, in all three groups, also had excision of her endometriosis along with the bowel surgery. The authors say doctors often miss intestinal endometriosis on bowel tests. So surgery itself is often needed to find it. This study reports surgery time, hospital stay, and charges.

Abstract

Objective

To compare three methods of segmental lower colon resection for treatment of symptomatic intestinal endometriosis.

Design

Retrospective case study.

Setting

Private practice patients in a rural community hospital.

Patients

Patients with nodular, invasive rectosigmoid endometriosis requiring segmental resection and anastomosis for treatment. Laparotomy patients were matched with laparoscopy patients for severity of intestinal endometriosis.

Interventions

Segmental resection of the rectosigmoid colon by laparotomy, by a laparoscopic Intracorporeal technique or by a laparoscopically assisted transvaginal technique.

Main Outcome Measures

Length of surgery, length of hospital stay, operating room charges and total hospital charges corrected to 1995 dollars.

Results

Compared with laparotomy segmental colon resection for endometriosis, laparoscopic transvaginal segmental resection resulted in a shorter length of stay, equivalent operating room charges, and significantly lower total hospital charges. The laparoscopic transvaginal technique is much faster, safer, and less fatiguing to the surgeon than a total intracorporeal technique.

Conclusions

Laparoscopically assisted transvaginal segmental rectosigmoid resection for endometriosis is a promising technique that is simpler than a laparoscopic intracorporeal segmental resection technique and is less costly than a laparotomy segmental resection technique.

By this author

Related research

David B. Redwine, Marinus Koning, Dean R. Sharpe
Dave Redwine, D Redwine, M Koning, D Sharpe
DOI 10.1016/s0015-0282(16)58051-0 10.1016/s0015-0282(16)58051-0 Redwine et al. 1996, Redwine 1996