Reproductive Endocrinology Ovarian Hormones

The interactive effects of estrogen and progesterone on changes in emotional eating across the menstrual cycle

Klump KL, Keel PK, Racine SE, Burt SA, Neale M, Sisk CL, Boker S, Hu JY

Published February 2013 Journal of abnormal psychology, 122(1), 131-7
DOI 10.1037/a0029524 PMID 22889242 PMC PMC3570621

RRM Academy Synopsis

Emotional eating peaks in the mid-luteal phase as hormones interact

In a 45-day study of 196 female twins aged 16 to 25, emotional eating scores were highest in the mid-luteal phase of the cycle. The twins gave daily ratings and saliva samples. Estradiol and progesterone together predicted the changes, and progesterone was linked to higher scores mainly when estradiol was also high.

Key Findings

  • Emotional eating differed by cycle phase (F(3,5890) = 6.57, p < .001). Mid-luteal scores exceeded ovulatory scores (p < .001) and premenstrual scores (p = .002).
  • Mid-luteal scores did not differ significantly from follicular scores (p = .61), though they appeared higher.
  • The estradiol x progesterone interaction significantly predicted emotional eating (p = .007). Progesterone alone showed a trend (p = .10) that weakened to p = .20 once the interaction was included.
  • Progesterone showed little-to-no effect on emotional eating at low estradiol. At high estradiol, the association was pronounced.
  • Emotional eating did not significantly predict estradiol (p = .92) or progesterone (p = .31) when the models were reversed.

Interpretation

The study followed community women with regular cycles and no hormonal medications. The design was observational, with daily repeated measures. Models adjusted for negative affect and body mass index. A questionnaire scale measured emotional eating, and the authors note that it does not assess binge episodes. They describe the findings as suggesting potential causal associations and call for studies that give hormones directly.

RRM Context

Progesterone peaks in the mid-luteal phase only after ovulation. The women in this study had regular cycles, so the eating changes tracked the hormone sequence of ovulatory cycles, the sequence that restorative reproductive medicine aims to support. Women who chart their cycles record the phase in which such changes occur.

Abstract

Studies suggest that within-person changes in estrogen and progesterone predict changes in binge eating across the menstrual cycle. However, samples have been extremely small (maximum N = 9), and analyses have not examined the interactive effects of hormones that are critical for changes in food intake in animals. The aims of the current study were to examine ovarian hormone interactions in the prediction of within-subject changes in emotional eating in the largest sample of women to date (N = 196). Participants provided daily ratings of emotional eating and saliva samples for hormone measurement for 45 consecutive days. Results confirmed that changes in ovarian hormones predict changes in emotional eating across the menstrual cycle, with a significant estradiol × progesterone interaction. Emotional eating scores were highest during the midluteal phase, when progesterone peaks and estradiol demonstrates a secondary peak. Findings extend previous work by highlighting significant interactions between estrogen and progesterone that explain midluteal increases in emotional eating. Future work should explore mechanisms (e.g., gene-hormone interactions) that contribute to both within- and between-subjects differences in emotional eating.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Reproductive Endocrinology › Ovarian Hormones › Estrogen · Menstrual Cycle › Cycle Physiology › Hormonal Regulation
Kelly L Klump, Pamela K Keel, Sarah E Racine, S Alexandra Burt, Michael Neale, Cheryl L Sisk, Steven Boker, Jean Yueqin Hu
K Klump, P Keel, S Racine, Mike Neale, M Neale, C Sisk, Steve Boker, S Boker, J Hu
PMID 22889242 22889242 DOI 10.1037/a0029524 10.1037/a0029524 Klump et al. 2013, Klump 2013